University of Kentucky Grants Humanist AI Exemption
The University of Kentucky has granted a research administrator a religious accommodation, exempting him from personally using artificial intelligence at work based on his humanist beliefs, in a first-of-its-kind case.

The University of Kentucky approved a religious accommodation for research administrator David Durman, exempting him from personal AI use while maintaining job responsibilities. The university granted the humanist-belief accommodation to the 45-year-old employee, determining it posed no undue burden on his department. University spokesperson Jay Blanton stated the institution reviews such requests individually, concluding an accommodation could be provided while Durman continued performing essential job functions.
Durman must still attend meetings where AI tools are used, and the accommodation does not change his job responsibilities or performance standards. He helps researchers apply for grants and is a humanist who does not believe in God. His objection focuses specifically on generative AI and large language models, not all artificial intelligence tools. Durman sees a distinction between tools like autocorrect and generative AI due to concerns about 'the offloading of cognitive ability' and decision-making.
The University of Kentucky's Office of Equal Opportunity granted the accommodation on September 25, 2026. The American Humanist Association announced it on October 26, confirming Durman is the first known humanist in the U.S. to receive such an exemption for AI use. Durman sought the accommodation after learning of a similar case, citing AI's environmental costs, interference with people's ability to earn a living, and supplanting of human creativity as reasons for his objection. He stated that using AI violates his deeply held Humanist beliefs which demand personal responsibility for the morality of his actions.
Legal foundation for religious AI exemptions
The accommodation follows Supreme Court precedents requiring substantial hardship justification for denying religious accommodations under Title VII. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 requires employers to reasonably accommodate religious practices unless doing so would impose an undue hardship. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission states that religious protections extend to people with sincerely held ethical or moral beliefs, not just traditional organized religions.
The Supreme Court's 2023 decision in Groff v. DeJoy clarified that an undue hardship requires 'substantial increased costs' rather than minimal cost to justify denying religious accommodation. Employers may deny accommodation requests if they impose an undue hardship. No court has ruled that humanist beliefs entitle workers to an AI-use exemption under Title VII. Durman's approval was voluntary and has not been tested in court.
Precedent and broader implications
Durman's case represents the first known secular humanist exemption for AI use, building on prior religious accommodations for AI objections. Erin Maus, a 34-year-old Unitarian Universalist software engineer in North Carolina, received a religious accommodation from her employer in May 2026. Maus argued that AI's environmental and ethical concerns conflicted with her Unitarian Universalist beliefs and completed a coding task by hand in about the same time as colleagues using AI.
Durman sought help from the American Humanist Association after learning of Maus's exemption. The AHA assisted Durman in preparing his accommodation request, with lawyer Alexandria Huiskens helping him submit it. Court Beyer, communications director for the AHA, stated the organization had found no previous publicly reported case of a humanist receiving a religious accommodation for AI use. The American Humanist Association said: "comprehensive non-theistic belief systems like Humanism are entitled to the same constitutional protections as other beliefs."
University context and employee beliefs
The University of Kentucky made Microsoft Copilot available campuswide on January 29, 2026, as part of its Commonwealth AI Transdisciplinary Strategy framework. The tool is available to more than 70,000 students and employees, though this represents access, not active usage. Approximately 2,000 faculty and staff participated in AI training between March and July 2026.
Durman objected to using AI tools such as Teams Copilot, Claude, and ChatGPT, viewing independent thought as part of his moral development. He has been a humanist for approximately 30 years, emphasizing human well-being, flourishing and individual responsibility for decisions. The university concluded the accommodation would not create an undue burden on Durman's department and approved it quickly. The AHA reported receiving several requests for assistance from other humanists seeking religious accommodations for AI use since Durman's case became public.





