ABA Moves to End First-Year Law Faculty Requirement
The ABA's accreditation council voted to eliminate a rule requiring full-time faculty to teach most first-year classes, a shift driven by a DOJ antitrust warning and federal recognition risks.

The American Bar Association’s accreditation council voted to nix a requirement that law schools have full-time faculty teach "substantially all" of their first-year classes. The vote occurred at a November 2026 meeting, one month after the U.S. Department of Justice warned the council it could face an antitrust investigation if it did not change the standard.
DOJ Antitrust Concerns Drive Policy Shift
The Justice Department threatened an antitrust probe over the requirement, arguing it drives up legal education costs. Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward warned in an October letter that the ABA could face an antitrust investigation if it did not eliminate the full-time faculty requirement. "The group could face an antitrust investigation if it didn’t eliminate the full-time faculty requirement," Woodward said. The council is in communication with the Justice Department, a council spokesperson said Tuesday.
Federal Recognition at Risk with Pending DOE Decision
Losing federal recognition would prevent the ABA's accreditation council from serving as a gatekeeper to Title IV financial aid, though only five of the 200 accredited law schools rely on it for federal aid access. The Trump administration is scrutinizing the accreditation council, with a U.S. Department of Education staff report in August recommending the council lose federal recognition for non-compliance with over two dozen federal criteria and lack of independence from the ABA. A federal advisory panel deadlocked on whether to recommend the council lose federal recognition. Education Under Secretary Nicholas Kent is expected to make a final call on the matter.
University Perspectives Split on Pedagogical Impact
The University of Colorado Boulder’s law school faculty leadership opposed nixing the first-year full-time faculty requirement, arguing it is critical for teaching core principles, building student community, and providing pedagogical expertise. The faculty leaders stated full-time faculty are more available for student questions outside class and build pedagogical expertise in course design, sequencing, assessment, and feedback.
Terence Lau, dean of Syracuse University’s law school, supported the change, arguing it would reduce undue burden while preserving full-time faculty’s core role. Lau stated the current standard limits law schools from using sitting judges or emeritus professors for first-year instruction. The accreditation council plans to seek public comment on further potential changes to its policies regarding full-time instructors to provide more flexibility to law schools.
The ABA's House of Delegates will review the policy shift at its February meeting and provide feedback before the accreditation council makes the final decision. The accreditation council can make the final call on whether to implement the change after receiving that feedback. The council formally repealed its prior diversity standard in September after suspending it in February 2025. The final decision rests with Education Under Secretary Nicholas Kent.





