Quad and Cloister
Live
Institutions

Supreme Court to decide Title IX employment claims for university staff

The Supreme Court will hear arguments on November 30, 2026, in Crowther v. Board of Regents, a case that will determine if employees of federally funded universities can sue for sex discrimination under Title IX.

Institutions: The Supreme Court will hear arguments on November 30, 2026, in Crowther v

The Supreme Court will hear arguments in Crowther v. Board of Regents of the University System of Georgia on November 30, 2026. The case will decide whether employees of federally funded educational institutions can sue their employers for sex discrimination under Title IX. Both plaintiff Thomas Crowther and former coach MaChelle Joseph sued the university system's regent board alleging such discrimination.

Lower courts split on Title IX employment claims

The 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed both Title IX claims. It ruled the 1972 law did not provide individuals with a right to sue for sex discrimination in employment. This decision conflicts with rulings from eight other federal appellate courts that permit such lawsuits. The 5th and 7th Circuits have blocked them, creating conflicting legal standards nationwide.

Precedent from Jackson v. Birmingham Board of Education

The Supreme Court previously ruled 5-4 in Jackson v. Birmingham Board of Education in 2005. That decision found an implied right to sue under Title IX, allowing a school employee to proceed with a lawsuit. Miriam Becker-Cohen, senior appellate counsel at the Constitutional Accountability Center, said this precedent strengthens the current case. "Jackson only makes that case even stronger because Jackson involved a school employee," she stated.

Key distinctions between Jackson and Crowther cases

Legal experts note important differences between the two cases. Jon Israel, a management-side sports and employment law attorney, explained that Jackson involved an implied right to sue. Crowther concerns a direct right to sue for nonstudents at higher education institutions. He stated the Crowther case is more distinguishable from Jackson due to these differing legal contexts.

The cases stem from two separate employment disputes within the University System of Georgia. Georgia Tech fired head women’s basketball coach MaChelle Joseph in 2019 after she filed an internal complaint alleging discrimination in resources compared to the men’s team. The university stated Joseph was terminated following an independent investigation that found some players felt bullied by her. In 2020, Augusta University reassigned and did not renew the contract of fine arts professor Thomas Crowther after a Title IX investigation into an anonymous sexual harassment complaint.

Potential impact on student-athletes

A ruling against the plaintiffs could have significant consequences for college athletes. If athletes are someday deemed employees, they could lose Title IX remedies for sex discrimination. They might be forced to pursue claims under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act instead. Israel contended that if student-athletes become employees and Title VII is the exclusive remedy, disparate treatment claims based on sport revenue could disappear.

Legal arguments center on whether Title VII provides sufficient recourse. Gregory Garre, former U.S. solicitor general, argued Title VII applies to employees and provides ample recourse, suggesting Congress did not intend Title IX to cover employment discrimination. Becker-Cohen disagreed, noting Title VII has a tighter 180-day statute of limitations and requires exhausting Equal Employment Opportunity Commission complaints before suing, unlike Title IX.

Barbara Osborne, a sports law professor at UNC Chapel Hill, stated Title VII is based on employee sex, while Title IX claims often involve retaliation for complaining about sex discrimination in athletics. She noted Title IX regulations include employment provisions, questioning why such regulations were created if employment situations were identical to normal employment. The Supreme Court's decision will determine if university employees can directly sue institutions under Title IX or must rely solely on Title VII through EEOC complaints.

Related coverage

More from Institutions