Botstein Denies Email Authenticity Amid Congressional Probe
A forensic report commissioned by Bard College's board found a 'strong substantive basis' to question the authenticity of an email attributed to former president Leon Botstein, which is central to a congressional request for a federal criminal investigation into his conduct.

A forensic cybersecurity investigation has raised serious doubts about the origin and integrity of an email attributed to former Bard College President Leon Botstein. The disputed correspondence with Jeffrey Epstein is now at the center of a congressional probe into Botstein's conduct. FTI Cybersecurity, commissioned by Bard's Board of Trustees, concluded there is a 'strong substantive basis for questioning the authenticity, integrity, and origin' of the email exchange.
FTI's 19-page report found the disputed emails did not exist on Bard's servers as of July 2017. The search included Google Vault records, historical correspondence, and logs from a 2017 server migration. The email lacked native transmission metadata and independently preserved source records needed to verify its sender, chronology, or integrity. Notably, the email was not an original message but one forwarded by Jeffrey Epstein to himself, a practice for which Epstein had a documented history of editing content.
The email's formatting also raised red flags. Its dateline read 'Sent: thurs 6 AM,' which did not match the style of other authenticated emails between Botstein and Epstein that included full dates, years, and timestamps. The message, dated May 14, 2014, included the phrase 'I am only available on sat,' referring to Saturday, May 17. Botstein's calendar for that day showed a packed schedule that directly contradicted this claim.
Congressional Probe Intensifies
Congress has launched a formal request for a federal criminal investigation into Botstein's conduct. The disputed email was publicized by U.S. Rep. Jamie Raskin, who has been investigating ties to Epstein since June. Raskin's letter to federal authorities alleged Botstein used his position to influence Title IX proceedings and protect sexual predators on Bard's faculty. His investigation draws from a trove of exchanges beyond the single disputed email.
Following the publication of Raskin's letter, Bard students and alumni protested against sexual abuse on campus. The congressional request seeks an investigation by the FBI and Department of Justice.
Botstein's Denial and Timeline Contradictions
Leon Botstein has consistently denied any involvement with the email. "As I previously said, I did not author or send that email," Botstein stated. The forensic findings support his denial with concrete evidence. The email exchange in question includes a response from Botstein to Epstein that was timestamped more than five hours before Epstein's original email was supposedly sent.
Botstein's calendar for May 17, 2014, provides a detailed account that contradicts the email's claim of availability. The schedule shows he departed Bard at 8 a.m. for Cambridge, Massachusetts, arriving at noon to attend a 1:15 p.m. commencement at the Longy Conservatory of Music. His evening was booked with a rehearsal for the Conservatory Orchestra from 7:30 to 10:30 p.m.
The email itself referenced a young woman described as a victim of Epstein's abuse. It was nested within a message Epstein forwarded to himself and was not found in the DOJ's Epstein document library. In a similar past incident, Epstein sent self-directed emails making false allegations about Bill Gates.
Fallout and Institutional Response
The controversy has led to significant leadership changes at Bard. Botstein resigned from all remaining roles at the college on October 7, following Raskin's call for a federal probe. This included stepping down from the graduate orchestra and summer music festival he founded and led.
Bard College stated it is committed to transparency and due process, noting its review of claims in Raskin's letter remains ongoing. One faculty member, composer and music professor Kyle Gann, was placed on administrative leave following an accusation. The institution's handling of campus safety continues under scrutiny as the forensic report fuels doubts about a key piece of evidence in the congressional investigation.





