Quad and Cloister
Live
Countries

New accreditation rules require focus on academic freedom

The U.S. Department of Education has finalized regulations overhauling college accreditation, easing entry for new agencies and mandating consideration of campus intellectual diversity policies.

The U.S. Department of Education has finalized regulations overhauling college accreditation, easing entry for new...

The U.S. Department of Education released final regulations on Thursday to revamp the college accreditation system. The new rules, which take effect July 1, ease pathways for new accreditors and introduce requirements for evaluating campus policies on academic freedom and intellectual diversity.

The department said it made "no substantive changes" to the August draft regulations and largely retained the language agreed upon with a committee of higher education representatives in the spring. The outcome of that negotiated rulemaking process bound the agency to much of the approved text. Under Secretary of Education Nicholas Kent said the final rule creates "a more competitive and transparent accreditation system" and increases accountability for colleges.

Academic freedom and intellectual diversity criteria

Accreditors must now consider a college's policies and practices related to academic freedom and intellectual diversity. When evaluating an institution, agencies must consider if it has academic freedom and freedom of inquiry protections, as well as policies designed to support and promote intellectual diversity and the free exchange of ideas among faculty.

The final rule will ensure accrediting agencies prioritize diversity of thought on campuses, the agency stated. Accrediting agencies are also barred from enforcing illegal diversity, equity, and inclusion requirements as defined by the Trump administration. However, an accreditor that does not adopt a formal policy on academic freedom or intellectual diversity will not be found out of federal compliance solely on that basis. An agency must consider relevant institutional policies in the context of its existing standards and the institution's mission.

Reaction from the accreditation community

The Council for Higher Education Accreditation (CHEA) expressed disappointment with the final rule. CHEA President Nasser Paydar said in a statement that many of the central concerns raised by CHEA and the higher education community remain largely unresolved. Paydar highlighted concerns around possible impacts on institutional academic freedom, as well as the potential for increased regulatory burdens and costs.

Implementation timeline and process

The final rule is set to publish Friday in the Federal Register. The Education Department accepted public comment on the rule for a month, the minimum window required by law. During that period, the agency said it afforded the public a substantial opportunity for meaningful input and received some 7,000 responses.

The department rejected requests to phase in the new accreditation regulations. Officials stated the eight months between the rule's publication and its July 1 effective date is sufficient time for accreditors to update standards, policies, and procedures to achieve compliance. Kent stated that for too long, accreditors have effectively served as a cartel to protect their interests, rather than the educational value that institutions are expected to deliver for students.

Easing entry for new accreditors

The new regulations make it easier for new accrediting agencies to gain federal recognition. They no longer need to be active for at least two years before seeking approval. Instead, new agencies can meet alternative criteria below.

Where an agency has adopted standards addressing these matters, it must apply and enforce those standards consistently. Accrediting agencies will now update their standards and procedures to meet the July 1 effective date.

Related coverage

More from Countries